Australian universities are routinely causing traumatic brain injury (TBI) in rats and mice by dropping weights onto their brains in an attempt to replicate the human condition.
In one closed head experiment (1) TBI was delivered to female adult rats using a custom built weight-drop device (figure 1). The animal’s head was placed directly under the guide tube and a 250g weight was released from a height of 1m onto the impact location. After impact the animal’s body fell 15 cm onto foam. Analgesia was then administered but the animals returned to consciousness 5 minutes after the injury. TBI was delivered repeatedly at one day intervals.
The University has recently acknowledged that animals are often not an ideal model for
scientific research but HRA holds the view that no animal model truly represents
the human condition and therefore results are unreliable.
Funding was provided to Melinda Fitzgerald by way of a Career Fellowship Grant from the National Health & Medical Research Council (NHMRC) (APP 1087114).
Figures (taken from the publication 1 )
Closed head impact TBI
Credit: Repeated mild traumatic brain injury in female rats increases lipid peroxidation in neurons; Nathanael J. Yates · Stephen Lydiard · Brooke Fehily · Gillian Weir · Aaron Chin · Carole A. Bartlett · Jacqueline Alderson, and Melinda Fitzgerald. Exp Brain Res DOI 10.1007/s00221-017-4958-8
Vivisectors at Monash University use the weight drop acceleration method on male Sprague-Dawley rats.
In these experiments, a metal disk is fixed to the exposed skull using dental acrylic. The animal is then disconnected from a ventilator and placed under a ‘trauma device’ whilst a 450g weight is dropped from 2 metres through a vertical tube onto the metal disk in the brain (2). After injury the rats were then re-attached to the ventilator and breathing resumed after approximately 5 minutes. They were then taken off the ventilator and the metal disk was removed. Electrodes were then inserted into the brain for recording purposes.
This research (2) was to study progesterone as a neuroprotective treatment option although the researchers themselves state there is already “a wealth of preclinical data concerning progesterone treatment of TBI”.
This research was funded by the National Health and Medical Research (via grant APP 1029311 to Ramesh Rajan et al).
What is the Accelerated Weight Drop Injury?
For a better understanding as how researchers induce TBI in the rat, the video below shows footage of a rat (both illustration and footage) undergoing preparation for closed heat repeated weight drop injury.
In experiments approved by the Florey Institute of Neuroscience and Mental Health, the University of Melbourne’s researchers have inflicted multiple traumatic brain injuries on the brains of mice both at 35 days of age and 70 days of age (3). After the TBI is caused, by way of blunt head trauma under a weight drop device, the mice undergo behavioural tests (including forced to swim for periods of time) to check for amnesia and gauge the severity of damage. The purpose was to study two development periods in the life of a mouse and test the hypothesis that a mild tBI during adolescence would predispose toward poor neurobehavioural and neuropathological outcomes after a subsequent injury at adulthood. In these mouse studies it did not – but we cannot rely on that for humans!
Again, the researchers were supported by grants from the NHMRC (being taxpayer dollars).
“Treatments that were neuroprotective in animals have, thus far, largely failed to translate in human clinical studies”
Dr Ashwin Kumaria, Department of Neurosurgery, Queen’s Medical Centre, Nottingham UK
Better Methods – In Vitro models
In his publication ‘In Vitro models as a platform to investigate traumatic brain injury’, Dr Ashwin Kumaria, Department of Neurosurgery at Queen’s Medical Centre, Nottingham, UK states that “Experimental in vivo models offer the potential to study TBI in the laboratory, however, treatments that were neuroprotective in animals have, thus far, largely failed to translate in human clinical studies. “In vitro (non animal) models of neurotrauma can be used to study specific pathophysiological cascades and to test potential neuroprotective strategies. These in vitro models include transection, compression, barotrauma, acceleration, hydrodynamic, chemical injury and cell-stretch methodologies. Various cell culture systems can also be utilized, including brain-on-a-chip, immortalized cell lines, primary cultures, acute preparations and organotypic cultures.
Relevance to Humans
According to Dr Andre Menache, BSc (Zoology), BSc(Hons), BVSc, MRCVS, “The study by these researchers falls under the heading of basic research, which by definition, makes no claim to clinical application. Animal researchers conducting these basic studies typically make some reference to human conditions in order to justify the funding of such endeavours”.
“The choice of the rat to study traumatic brain injury ignores species differences and evolutionary biology. The rat possesses a four layered lissencephalic cortex (humans possess a six layered gyrencephalic cortex) and are separated by 70 million years of evolution. These facts have important consequences when trying to extrapolate results from animal studies to humans. As an example, more than 1000 drugs have demonstrated neuroprotection in animal models (mostly rats) of experimental stroke. However, none have shown neuroprotection in humans. This represents a success rate of zero.”
Dr André Ménache, BSc(Hons) BVSc MRCVS, Director of Antidote Europe,
“Animal models of TBI incompletely represent the human situation in a number of ways, particularly with regard to size considerations and extensive anatomical and histological differences”
Dr Asin Kumaria, Department of Neurosurgery, Queen’s Medical Centre, Nottingham UK
COST BENEFIT ANALYSIS
The Australian and New Zealand Council for the Care of Animals in Research and Teaching states that: “Using animals for scientific purposes is acceptable only when any harm done to the animals is very greatly outweighed by the benefits of their use”. These studies are clearly an example of basic research which is defined as “experimental or theoretical work undertaken primarily to acquire new knowledge of the underlying foundations of phenomena and observable facts, without any particular application or use in view” (OECD definition).”
It is unclear in each case as to whether the authors could foresee any application of this work. The publications do not provide any evidence to show that the information obtained from the killing of these animals will lead to benefits for people with traumatic brain injury. It is simply basic research.
Studies of sensory processes and deficits in humans suffering TBI should instead be relied upon to provide information regarding cognitive processing and possible rehabilitation.
Australian Taxpayer Funded
All three research projects described here received government funding of one type or another – either by way of a substantial grant or for Career Development from the National Health and Medical Research Council (NHMRC) thereby Australian taxpayer funded.
What can you do?
Please use the form below to tell the National Health and Medical Research Council (NHMRC) how disappointed you are that the NHMRC funds animal research such as these traumatic brain injury experiments in rats and mice. You can use the text provided or compose your own.
Your message will be sent via email to the NHMRC.
You can also send your objections to the following institutions:
Prof Margaret Gardner
Monash University Vic 3800
The University of Western Australia
Prof Dawn Freshwater
The University of Western Australia
35 Stirling Highway
PERTH WA 6009
University of Melbourne
Prof Duncan Maskell
University of Melbourne
PARKVILLE Vic 3010
- Repeated mild traumatic brain injury in female rats increases lipid peroxidation in neurons; Nathanael J. Yates · Stephen Lydiard · Brooke Fehily · Gillian Weir · Aaron Chin · Carole A. Bartlett · Jacqueline Alderson, and Melinda Fitzgerald
Exp Brain Res DOI 10.1007/s00221-017-4958-8
- Progesterone Sharpens Temporal Response Profiles of Sensory Cortical Neurons in Animals Exposed to Traumatic Brain Injury
Benjamin J. Allitt, Victoria P. A. Johnstone, Katrina L. Richards, Edwin B. Yan, and Ramesh Rajan
Cell Transplantation 2017, Vol. 26(7) 1202-1223
- Mild Traumatic Brain injury in adolescent Mice alters skull Bone Properties to influence a subsequent Brain impact at adulthood: a Pilot study
Thomas J. McColl, Rhys D. Brady, Sandy R. Shultz, Lauren Lovick, Kyria M. Webster, Mujun Sun, Stuart J. McDonald, Terence J. O’Brien and Bridgette D. Semple
Frontiers in Neurology 2018, Vol 9 Article 372
- A Novel Model of Mild Traumatic Brain Injury for Juvenile Rats.
Mychasiuk, R., Farran, A., Angoa-Perez, M., Briggs, D., Kuhn, D., Esser, M. J.; J. Vis. Exp. (94), e51820, doi:10.3791/51820 (2014)